Featured Article from Software Licensing

Unmanaged Indirect Access to Software Can Create Licensing Headaches

March 09, 2017



The specifics of software licensing can often be frustrating and confusing, as demonstrated by the recent court case of SAP v. Diageo. Specifically, in instances of indirect access to a software product, customers can all too easily run afoul of licensing and compliance agreements, resulting in fees, fines and in the worst-case scenario, time wasted in litigation.

As we recently discussed, Diageo ended up in trouble after some 5,800 of its users accessed SAP’s (News - Alert) ERP software indirectly through a third-party application, in violation of their licensing agreement. The mistake was a costly one, ending with Diageo paying SAP UK more than $67 million in fines and compensation. Diageo is far from unique when it comes to indirect software licensing violations, and according to Flexera Software, the problem is more widespread and complex than most software manufacturers and customers realize.

Software companies typically license their products based on a variety of metrics, including a fixed count of processors in a server, a specific number of users or devices or based on the number of simultaneous users in some cases. However, customers often find themselves unintentionally and unknowingly in violation of these complex contracts by exceeding the agreed upon number of users, devices, etc. One of the points of confusion, according to Flexera, is over what constitutes a “named user.”

In the Diageo case, the company had thousands of “indirect” users who were accessing the SAP database through customer-facing applications on the Salesforce.com (News - Alert) platform. The apps were using a licensed SAP Process Integration interface to connect to SAP’s database, but the license didn’t technically cover the indirect users going through Salesforce. The U.K. court ultimately ruled that indirect users were different than the “named users” covered through Diageo’s licensing agreement, and the company suffered the financial consequences.

The case is a cautionary tale for all companies accessing SAP through an indirect license model. Fortunately there are ways to mitigate the risks of indirect access to SAP and other popular software platforms, using solutions like those offered by Flexera. The company offers its FlexNet Manager for SAP Applications, designed to optimize customers’ SAP named user licensing by finding idle users, identifying duplicate users and assigning optimal license types for each user based on usage data.

Software licensing and optimization management is critical to staying on top of compliance and agreement mandates, and particularly so in cases of indirect access. Companies connecting to SAP and other popular platforms via third-party interfaces and APIs need to be mindful of the rules surrounding indirect access and indirect users to ensure they achieve and maintain compliance with their licensing agreements.




Edited by Maurice Nagle
Article comments powered by Disqus


Free Trials

See For Yourself Why So Many Trust Flexera Software Solutions

Featured White Papers / eBooks

Report: Software Licensing 2016: Seismic Shifts - Shaky Foundations

Report: Software Licensing 2016: Seismic Shifts - Shaky Foundations
Key Trends in Software Pricing & Licensing Survey - 2016 Report...

eBook: How Can You Monetize the Internet of Things?

eBook: How Can You Monetize the Internet of Things?
This eBook provides 5 tips for leveraging your intelligent devices and apps to gain higher revenues, competitive advantages and lower costs as well as discusses software monetization and licensing use cases and success stories...

eBook: 10 Reasons to Buy a Purpose-built Software Monetization Solution

eBook: 10 Reasons to Buy a Purpose-built Software Monetization Solution
Read this eBook that arms you with 10 reasons to buy - and not build - that can be used to develop the business case for leveraging a commercial Software Monetization solution...

eBook: How Do I Transform My Hardware Business and Supply Chain Processes to Support a Software Business?

eBook: How Do I Transform My Hardware Business and Supply Chain Processes to Support a Software Business?
This eBook discusses the hardware to software shift, the changing business requirements for successfully managing a software business and provides guidance on next steps...

Featured Press Release

Featured Webinars

Networking Leader Shares Why Transforming their Business was Key to Leveraging NFV Market Trend

Networking Leader Shares Why Transforming their Business was Key to Leveraging NFV Market Trend
Attend this webinar to hear Richard Jenny, Director of Program Management and DevOps with ADVA Optical Networking discuss why they decided to leverage a Software Monetization platform instead of building their own software licensing, entitlement management and software update solution.

Expert Panel: Software Monetization Trends and Best Practices with IDC and Flexera Software
Join Software Monetization experts as they share predictions and best practices on the topics that are driving transformation in the technology industry. If you are a software vendor looking to adopt new subscription, usage and outcome-based business models or a device manufacturer looking to monetize your software and establish recurring revenue models, this panel discussion will address all these issues as well as the impacts of cloud, virtualization and IoT.

Webinar: Software Monetization Maturity Model - How to Get Your Organization to the Next Level
Application producers are faced with many challenges as they try to grow revenue and streamline back-office processes, and those that are thriving have adopted a strong and well thought out software monetization strategy